Poe & Conan Doyle & Native Language Identification
Last year, I wrote the literature review part of my thesis. In it, I mentioned stories about Sherlock Holmes and Detective Dupin , between intensive research papers on the topic of Native Language Identification (NLID). My advisor suggested I remove the half-page paragraph in favor of real, pertinent research. Her point was absolutely valid. Writing a literature review is a matter of reading published research relating to a thesis topic and writing a paper about those papers and how they support or otherwise affect one's thesis. Including two literary detectives was pure self-indulgence (and it would mean I could cite Edgar Allan Poe and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle in my bibliography). The two stories I mentioned are Poe's The Murders in the Rue Morgue and Conan Doyle's A Scandal in Bohemia . They both include the identification of native language, however briefly, as one of their respective clues. I have always found these fictional examples fascinating, and I think this bl...